Collision With a Wall (v' = -ev, Why Momentum Is Not Conserved, Kinetic Energy Lost)

Only the direction changes

When two balls collide, the sum of their momenta did not change. This time the partner is a wall.

The wall does not move, so the only thing to be settled is the velocity of the ball. Applying the definition of the coefficient of restitution as it stands gives .

The speed is multiplied by and the direction is reversed. At the speed is unchanged and only the direction turns. At the ball sticks to the wall and stops.

Notice that one equation was enough. The partner does not move, so there is no pair to solve together.

Momentum is not conserved

The momentum before the bounce is and after it is . These are not the same.

Look at the two bars in the figure. The direction has reversed, and the length has shrunk by a factor of as well. Far from a sum holding still, the one momentum there is has changed.

This does not mean the conservation law has stopped working. It is being applied to the wrong thing. Momentum is conserved in a system that receives no force from outside, and a ball considered by itself is receiving a force from the wall.

So this ball is not on its own. It has a partner outside it, namely the wall.

The wall took it

Where did the momentum the ball lost go? Into the wall.

The change for the ball is , that is, . By action and reaction, the wall receives momentum of the same size in the opposite direction.

The third bar in the figure is the sum of the two, and it does not move. Take the wall into the system and momentum is conserved after all.

The wall shows no sign of moving because its mass is larger by an enormous factor. The wall is joined to the building and the building to the Earth. Given the same momentum, a large in leaves a far too small to see.

Energy falls too

Look at the kinetic energy as well. Before it is ; after it is .

Taking the difference gives . The that appeared with two balls shows its face here as well.

At it is . Only the direction turns, and no energy is lost. The smaller is the more is lost, and at all of it goes.

The wall carried off momentum, but it does not carry off kinetic energy. The wall does not move, so no work is done on it. What is lost becomes heat, sound and a dent.

Uniform Acceleration SimulatorSlope is acceleration, area is displacementYou can solve it without the timeA negative acceleration is not always a slowdownFalling and throwing upward are one motion
Projectile Motion SimulatorHorizontal and vertical move separatelyWhat disappears is the timeThe farthest throw is at 45°
Friction SimulatorFriction does as it is toldIt is set by how hard the surface is pressedThe angle of slipping does not depend on weight
Leaning Ladder SimulatorBalanced forces can still topple itThe wall is smooth, the floor is roughThe more upright, the safer
Pulley SimulatorAdd the equations and the tension goesTension is not the weightIt takes weight to get it moving
Roller Coaster SimulatorThe path makes no differenceHeavy in the valley, light on the hillIt takes two and a half times the height
Conservation of Momentum SimulatorImpulse changes momentumThey cancel on the insideThe second equation is the restitution
Collision SimulatorThe wall carries the momentum offEvery bounce multiplies it by e²Infinitely many bounces, and it stops
Circular Motion SimulatorConstant speed and still acceleratingThere is no such force as centripetal forceThe flatter it lies, the faster it turns
Spring Pendulum SimulatorSimple harmonic motion is a circle's shadowVelocity and acceleration are shadows tooEnergy only changes its form
Simple Pendulum SimulatorA small swing is the same as a springHeight decides the speedIn an accelerating train the vertical tilts
Planetary Orbit SimulatorThe Moon is falling tooThe nearer in, the fasterThe period is set by the size of the orbitFast enough and it never returns